Having cabinets either above or below the countertop on a kitchen island can impact the overall design and functionality of your kitchen space. Here are the pros and cons of each option:
Cabinets Above the Countertop (Overhead Cabinets):
Pros:
Additional Storage: Overhead cabinets provide extra storage space for kitchen essentials, such as cookware, dishes, and small appliances. This is especially beneficial in smaller kitchens where storage is limited.
Concealment: Items stored in overhead cabinets are hidden from view, creating a cleaner and more organized look in the kitchen.
Accessibility: Depending on the cabinet design, certain items might be more accessible at eye level or with the use of pull-out shelves, making it easier to reach items without bending down.
Cons:
Visual Weight: Overhead cabinets can make the kitchen island area feel visually heavy and closed off, especially if the cabinets are dark or bulky.
Restricted Space: The presence of overhead cabinets might reduce the open and airy feeling of the kitchen, which is often desired in modern kitchen designs.
Head Clearance: If the cabinets hang too low, they can limit headroom and become a potential hazard, especially for taller individuals.
Cabinets Below the Countertop (Base Cabinets):
Pros:
Open and Spacious Feel: Cabinets below the countertop can create a more open and visually light kitchen island area, making the space feel larger and inviting.
Island Seating: Without overhead cabinets, it's easier to incorporate seating at the kitchen island, allowing it to serve as a dining or entertaining area.
Showcase Countertop Material: Cabinets below the countertop can provide an opportunity to showcase beautiful countertop materials without obstruction.
Cons:
Reduced Storage: With no overhead cabinets, you lose out on potential storage space, which might be a disadvantage for kitchens with limited storage options.
Visible Clutter: Since items are not concealed, you need to maintain a tidy and organized interior of the base cabinets to avoid visible clutter.
Bending and Stooping: Accessing items in base cabinets might require more bending down, which can be less ergonomic for some individuals.
Ultimately, the decision between having cabinets above or below the countertop on your kitchen island depends on your specific needs, kitchen layout, and design preferences. You can also explore a combination of both options, using overhead cabinets in certain areas and base cabinets in others to achieve a balance of functionality and aesthetics.