Whether to keep your old liquid propane main heat source stove fireplace or swap it out for a wood or pellet stove depends on various factors, including your preferences, budget, and specific circumstances. Here are some considerations to help you make an informed decision:
Cost and Efficiency: Propane, wood, and pellet stoves each have different costs associated with fuel and installation. Propane is generally more expensive than wood or pellets. Wood stoves require a steady supply of firewood, and pellet stoves use compressed sawdust pellets, which can also add to the cost. Consider the long-term operating costs and the availability of fuel in your area.
Environmental Impact: Wood and pellet stoves are often considered more environmentally friendly than propane stoves, as wood and pellets are renewable resources. However, wood burning can contribute to local air pollution, so if you are concerned about air quality in your area, pellet stoves may be a better option, as they typically produce fewer emissions.
Convenience: Propane stoves are generally more convenient to use, as they require less maintenance and cleaning compared to wood or pellet stoves. With a propane stove, you won't need to worry about storing firewood or pellets, and you can easily control the flame with the turn of a knob.
Heating Capacity: Consider the heating capacity of each stove type. Propane stoves tend to provide consistent and controllable heat output. Wood stoves can produce intense heat but may require more active management to maintain a steady temperature. Pellet stoves offer automated temperature control and can provide a more even heat output.
Power Outages: If your area experiences frequent power outages, a propane stove may be a better option since it doesn't rely on electricity to operate, unlike pellet stoves, which require electricity to run the auger and fan.
Aesthetics and Ambiance: Wood stoves offer a classic and cozy ambiance with a real flame and the crackling sound of burning wood. Some people prefer the traditional feel of a wood-burning stove for its aesthetics.
Safety Considerations: All types of stoves require proper installation, maintenance, and adherence to safety guidelines. Be sure to follow local building codes and have the stove professionally installed and inspected.
In the end, the choice between keeping your existing propane stove or switching to a wood or pellet stove depends on your personal preferences, budget, environmental concerns, and heating needs. If you are unsure about which option is best for your situation, it's a good idea to consult with a professional stove installer or a heating specialist who can assess your home's specific requirements and help you make an informed decision.